With a flick of its tail, the giant disappears, leaving an indelible mark on the cobalt blue expanse. Time feels suspended as the weight of the ocean envelops, with no immediate context to ground the observer. Moments earlier, the water thrummed with the presence of a creature so vast that it consumed every inch of the view.
Every detail is clear: the whale’s skin shimmers like brushed steel beneath a circle of sunlight cast from above. Its folds resemble mountainous landscapes, and scars tell a story of survival. Yet, the overwhelming presence of this 45-ton behemoth exudes tranquility, allowing for a fleeting connection that feels as profound as a flash of green just before sunset. As it descends into darkness, the sperm whale fades from sight, slipping into an incomprehensible realm.
The allure of these elusive deep-divers has been a source of intrigue for centuries. They can plunge 5,000 feet to hunt giant squid. In the pages of Herman Melville’s Moby Dick, they are depicted as fiercely intelligent creatures, much like Jonah who sought refuge within the belly of one. The allure even extends to the world of perfumery, where ambergris, a rare secretion from sperm whales, was once key in concocting Chanel No. 5.
In the Caribbean, Dominica stands out as one of the only two places globally that legally permits swimming with sperm whales, with Sri Lanka as the other. Here, a coastal shelf drops steeply, providing access to a resident population of 200 whales as they nurse and raise their young.
Dubbed the ‘nature island,’ Dominica’s lush landscape includes nine active volcanoes and the Boiling Lake, a flooded volcanic crater bubbling like a cauldron. Rising to 4,747 feet, its terrain is rich with dense rainforest.
Home to approximately 66,000 residents, the vibrant communities contrast sharply with better-known vacation spots like Barbados. Just a fraction of the land has been developed, largely due to the rugged landscape that once posed challenges to colonial powers.
However, significant investments are on the horizon, including a $200 million marina project and a cable car to the Boiling Lake. These developments aim to welcome more tourists via cruise ships and an airport expected to open by late 2027.
Balancing economic growth with environmental preservation is paramount, especially in a country where the economy remains sluggish. The average annual wage sits at $9,000, emphasizing the need for development.
Jackson Mawhinney, co-founder of the eco-tourism initiative Diving with Giants, advocates for a focus on upscale tourism. As he navigates the frothy waters in search of whales, he claims that remoteness has become the new luxury. Guiding the future development awaits responsible execution.
Mawhinney, son of Baroness Patricia Scotland, divides his time between London and Dominica, eager to contribute back to his roots. Only a few companies hold permits to dive with sperm whales, and Diving with Giants is among them. The venture began with a shared vision alongside photographer Adam Slama, leading to collaborations with adventure planners Eyos Expeditions, offering sea tours aboard the superyacht Solace Odyssey.

©Eyos Expeditions
Joined the 187-foot yacht a day prior in Antigua’s English Harbour, the voyage reveals Dominica’s charm as the clouds lift. Sunbeams outline the island’s natural contours, presenting a raw beauty. Despite the initial unsuccessful whale-watching, after exploring the geothermal vents at Champagne Bay, spirits remain high. With the mating season in full swing, more whales are anticipated.
Solace Odyssey, built in 2005 and recently refurbished, stands out with its minimalist design. Its interiors, created by Vickers Studio, mirror its Scandinavian owner’s aesthetics, showcasing a fine art photograph that complements its serene atmosphere. Guests can enjoy various activities like jetboarding and stand-up paddleboarding.
Not merely a yacht, Solace represents an expedition spirit, following a global itinerary that allows for private charters. The aim is to create a cohesive narrative for returning guests.
Beyond leisure, Eyos Expeditions co-manages Yachts for Science, which collaborates with scientists seeking to utilize vessels during idle periods. Solace is already slated to assist in a humpback whale study in exchange for knowledge-sharing opportunities with its guests.
Conversations with marine experts augment the experience. The evening brings Nawana Shillingford, Dominica’s assistant maritime administrator, who was instrumental in establishing the world’s first Sperm Whale Reserve. The initiative protects a vast area from commercial activity, reflecting a commitment to marine conservation.
Shillingford describes the connection locals feel toward their marine neighbors, endowed with familial names hinting at endearment. Recognizing the vital role these creatures play in carbon sequestration, she emphasizes their unmatched value.
Despite unclear regulations around permits, Shillingford reassures that ecological preservation triumphs over profit. Dominica is selective in its tourism approach, offering an exclusive experience. The following day, as morning rains blur the horizon, a sense of privilege envelops the chosen few fortunate enough to venture into the waters.
Contemplating the previous day’s encounter, feelings of trepidation dissipated beneath the waves. Underwater, distances distort perception, amplifying every sound and movement.
Gabriel Armour, a seasoned local boatman contracted by Diving with Giants, employs a homemade hydrophone to detect whale vocalizations. A simple yet effective device reveals clicks that shape the underwater dialogue and beckon the observer to join.
Swimming through turbulent waters, the magnificent form of a sperm whale emerges. Time stretches in its grace. Moving alongside its majestic silhouette, an eye meets mine, creating an unspoken understanding of shared existence in the vast ocean.
Mawhinney’s conviction rings true as the whales retreat into visibility. Witnessing the playful maneuvering of youngsters underscores the interconnectedness of their lives—an intricate web of mobility and interaction.
Mawhinney reflects that the sperm whale’s expansive brain and intricate behaviors invite speculation about their intelligence. Researcher Shane Gero, dedicated to decoding their communication patterns, shares insights about their familial relationships and communication complexity.
He notes that studying the Caribbean sperm whale population offers special advantages due to their predictable behaviors. Observing their interactions, Gero teases apart the layers of what might appear as monotonous routines disrupted by unexpected displays of life.
Amidst the potential dangers of close encounters, environmental shifts prompt concern. Gero highlights how human activities threaten their habitats, with a pressing need to ensure a symbiotic relationship between people and marine creatures.
Exploring the island with Mawhinney, a sense of urgency for sustainable practices prevails. The aim is to protect Dominica’s natural beauty while providing for its inhabitants. No desire exists to replicate the excessive development seen elsewhere.
A cleansing ritual at Syndicate Falls conducted by a Kalinago shaman connects participants with the land and its traditions. The essence of nature infiltrates daily life, reflected in the vibrant natural world providing for its people.
The aftermath of Hurricane Maria in 2017 lingers as a reminder of vulnerability in the face of nature’s wrath. Rebuilding has tested resilience, but it has also sparked awareness of the fragility of existence amidst climate change and ecological balance.
As ambitions for the future loom, the wisdom of restraint prevails. The unseen depths hold mysteries that may forever elude grasp, yet there is solace in their imperviousness, a poignant reminder of what it means to inhabit a world intertwined with nature.
Solace Odyssey will operate in Dominica from mid-November to March, starting at $457,119 per week.
